Hannah Swenson is up to her ears with Easter orders rushing in at the Cookie Jar, plus a festive meal to prepare for a dinner party at her mother's penthouse. But in this 27th case (following Christmas Cupcake Murder), everything comes crashing to a halt when Hannah receives a panicked call from her sister Andrea, who is considered the prime suspect in the murder of Mayor Richard Bascomb. As children line up for Easter egg hunts, Hannah must manage her store while springing into investigation mode to identify the real killer before another murder happens.